
Climate advisers warn that weaker electric-car targets could raise UK oil demand
A letter to the transport secretary sets out what the Climate Change Committee thinks is at stake in the review of Britain’s zero-emission vehicle rules.
News & analysisThe Climate Change Committee has warned ministers that easing Britain’s electric-vehicle sales rules could leave the country buying more oil in 2030 and make its climate targets harder to reach. The committee published a letter to Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander on Wednesday as the government reviews the rules that require manufacturers to sell a rising proportion of zero-emission vehicles.
The independent adviser cited government modelling that implied a cut to the headline targets could increase UK oil consumption by the equivalent of 15 million barrels annually by 2030. At the prices used by the committee, it estimated that would add more than £1 billion a year to the cost of buying oil. The figure depends on how sales targets change, what vehicles are sold as a result and future oil prices.
Sales rules shape the fleet over time
The mandate applies to the composition of manufacturers’ sales. A change would affect the mix of vehicles entering the fleet each year. Cars bought today can keep using fuel for years, so the emissions impact of a different sales mix would build as those vehicles accumulated on the road.
The committee says electric vehicles account for the largest portion of the emissions cuts anticipated under the government’s delivery plan through 2037. It points particularly to the sixth carbon budget, which covers 2033 to 2037. The letter also asks that the review account for the effect of any change on the separate carbon budgets in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
The adviser’s case extends to exposure to fuel prices. When more journeys depend on petrol and diesel, a rise in internationally traded oil prices can feed into household and business costs. The practical cost of switching to an electric vehicle varies, including with purchase price, mileage and where the driver can charge. The committee frames its estimate as part of the national case for preserving the targets.
Analysis · What to watch in the review
The government’s eventual decision can be assessed against two separate questions. The first is whether any adjustments change how many zero-emission vehicles manufacturers are expected to sell over the next several years. The second is what the government intends to do about any emissions gap left by a change. A decision that addresses only manufacturers’ near-term obligations would leave the latter question open.
The committee’s letter provides a comparison against which ministers’ proposals can be read. The dates, expected sales mix and modelling assumptions matter more than the label attached to a revision. Wednesday’s warning sets out the adviser’s assessment while ministers consider how to proceed.